The LTB Network Forum


Did Margin Trading Crash the Price of Bitcoin?

Back to Crypto-News

Jump to bottom

Comments

virtapayseller

The price of bitcoin declined to its lowest level since May yesterday, falling nearly 10% and ending what had been a long period of relative optimism and stability for the global bitcoin market.

But while there were many theories as to what news events could have caused bitcoin’s value to fall into such a steep decline, some market observers believe that this most recent movement may have been caused not by external factors, but by the actions of bitcoin traders.

This theory, perhaps most notably posed by Raffael Danielli, posits that out-of-control margin trading caused a flash crash in at least one major bitcoin exchange market, a development that had a cascading effect across the larger bitcoin market.

In the post on his quantitative analysis blog Matlab Trading, Danielli asserts that margin traders, specifically those on Hong Kong-based bitcoin trading platform Bitfinex, had invested significant funds into long positions as bullish sentiment rose in July.

Speaking to CoinDesk, Danielli elaborated on his post, suggesting that initial positive sentiment about New York’s proposed bitcoin regulation had a profound impact on the digital currency trading community, but that it was how investors acted on this information that proved problematic.

Danielli explained:

“[Positive sentiment about US regulation] resulted in large buying activities and traders on Bitfinex started to borrow as much money as they [could] to buy more bitcoins and increase their position in anticipation of a market upswing. As it turned out, New York’s proposed bitcoin regulations are more on the harsh side and the European banking authority also decided to take a very cautious approach.”

He concluded: “In other words, many traders were caught on the wrong foot and today they paid the price.”

The rise of bitcoin margin trading

Margin trading allows investors to borrow money from brokers, funds that are then leveraged by borrowers to trade on the outlook of bitcoin. Borrowers can then place bets on how they believe the market will perform, going either ‘long’ or ‘short’ depending on whether they think the price of the asset will rise (long) or fall (short).

When margin traders close their position, they return the original principal to the investor, plus any agreed upon interest, and the borrower is assessed a profit or a loss.

While a mainstay of major traditional markets, margin trading is relatively new to the bitcoin ecosystem. China’s largest bitcoin exchange OKCoin introduced its margin trading service this June, while Bitfinex opened its offering in June of 2013. BTC-e, another major Europe-based exchange, also offers the service.

Though he is a critic of margin trading, Danielli was quick to point out that the practice is not something that’s unique to the bitcoin ecosystem.

“All major exchanges in the world such as NASDAQ, NYSE and BATS have to deal with similar events like the one we observed today.”

Proponents of margin trading assert that the trading option provides experienced investors with the chance to gain significant profits, provided they properly gauge the risks associated with their borrowing.

for more you can read here http://www.coindesk.com/margin-trading-crash-price-bitcoin/

2 likes
  • ThinkTank

    The concept of a $600.00 stop run seems more plausible. IMO as margin by itself is a double edge sword and mute, vs the concept of "naked shorting" to borrow a wall st phase doesn't really exist in this ecosystem with items sold and then located like in a typical brokerage system. Markets tend to move because the have to, meaning one party is becoming more aggressive and willing to give up bid ask spread to make the trade, as they swing from fear to greed, and vise versa.

    Permalink
    0 likes
  • Disengage

    Forgive the stupid question, but I'm not a trader. I can see how being on the wrong side of a bet involving margin could be bad for the borrower, but how does this cause the price of BTC to fall?

    Permalink
    0 likes
  • ThinkTank

    The margin issue is mute point as a reason to make the market fall, as margin is also the very reason you have buyers driving it up.

    Think of a thinly traded market, with a automatically triggered order that says sell at any price once my level is breached! And this forced sell regardless of where the next bid is resting is what causes large moves.

    If the market was thick meaning large liquidity this wouldn't be a factor as the orders would be absorbed with little effect on price but btC is a thin market a few orders drive price down and these orders feed on a negative loop.

    It's a liquidity issue not a margin issue. If there is lack of news.

    And it's a good question, and the original article is misapplying margin as a cause, IMHO.

    Permalink
    3 likes
  • kennycud

    Despite what the original author claims, margin trading did not make the BTC price go down. Despite what the main stream media claimed a few years ago, margin trading did not make gas prices go up!

    Permalink
    0 likes
Jump to top

Post Reply

Please Login to post a reply to this thread.

© Copyright 2013–2016 The LTB Network. All rights reserved .