The LTB Network Forum


Ukraine, Bitcoin, and History

Back to General

Jump to bottom

Comments

cmason


(this was initially published on the Ethereum forum at forum.ethereum.org.  They explicitly granted permission for publishing political articles. I have not received this here, although I have received positive comments and no admonition not to publish. I hope this is sufficient to permit my publication.
I will post the article here, but if you wish to see comments, please view the original here:
http://forum.ethereum.org/discussion/614/ukraine-bitcoin-and-history
However, in the spirit of this forum, I believe most discussion should take place here.  I was almost convinced not to publish this, but the extreme comments assured me I was doing the right thing.)
During the protests in Ukraine, several articles were written about protesters asking for donations in Bitcoin. Two points were being made: one, this was a great way for people around the world to support the protesters, especially when moving money in and out of Ukraine was becoming increasingly difficult, and second, how it was disappointing that they had received less Bitcoin than the football fan who famously made over $20,000 by getting his Bitcoin sign, with QR code, on ESPN.
But I don't think that's very important, I don't think it made any difference, I don't think it was a good idea, and I'm glad I didn't send any money. I know, I wanted to start talking about politics because of how I believe Bitcoin can change the world. So what better way to start than by talking about how it can't?
Of course, these articles were posted before Russia annexed Crimea, and before a lot of details about the strange mix of parties and interests that took over Ukraine became more widely known.
Clearly the majority of protestors were simply unhappy with President Viktor Yanukovych. Their resentments included concerns about his relationship with Moscow and with general corruption. But some disturbing groups were also involved in the protests, and now play a role in the new government established after the former president fled the country.
These groups are often referred to as "right-wing" or "ultra-right-wing", but I will refrain from calling them that. There are many conservative parties in the world that might be colloquially referred to as "right-wing" and there is nothing wrong with these parties. The parties and groups I am referring to here are something else entirely.
I don't mean to be oblique, but I want to forestall any attempt to apply Godwin's law. Because when you are talking about groups and parties composed of people were are descended from, inspired by, and sometimes actually including, members of the Waffen SS and the Nazi party, then Godwin's law does not apply. These are not people to be compared to Nazis, these are actual, real Nazis. These are the true anti-semites, although the term has been so overused and misused in recent times to the extent it has been shamefully cheapened. These are the real fascists, and I used the word plainly, not as what John Michael Greer would describe as a "snarl word".
As many are now aware, in 1954, Soviet First Secretary Nikita Khrushchev administratively transferred Crimea from the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic to the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic, a bureaucratic move that made almost no difference to anyone. Indeed, if, in Canada, Labrador was to be administratively transferred from Newfoundland to Québec, this would have a greater political impact than the transfer done by Khrushchev.
It is an accident of history that Crimea ended up a part of a new country called Ukraine after the collapse of the Soviet Union. That doesn't give anyone the right to invade and occupy the territory, but it does give some perspective.
I don't like Russia's government and policies. Vladimir Putin may be a de facto dictator, homophobe and master manipulator, but when he talks about Ukrainian Nazis, he's not just blustering, he's telling the truth. I don't want people in the Ukraine or Crimea to suffer. I hope a peaceful end is eventually reached. I also don't want a cent of my money to reach the thugs in Ukraine trying to grasp at the levers of power, and desperately trying to recreate the horrors of the past.
But how did this all start? It started because the government of Ukraine was bankrupt, and corrupt, and this not only breeds discontent, it gives extreme elements more of a chance to infiltrate society and spread their message. When people lack hope, they are more likely to listen to extreme messages. This isn't unique, we've seen the same thing in Greece with Golden Dawn, and similar movements, large or small, throughout Europe.
Maybe if Bitcoin, or something like it, had been available 10 years ago, other options might have been available to the people. They might have been able to sustain businesses through greater international sales, services, supply contracts, and other import/export arrangements, while also developing a more robust local economy free from interference from the state.
I won't pretend that Bitcoin is a simple fix that could have solved everyone's problems, but it would have given people more options, more freedom, and more flexibility. Sending Bitcoin donations to Ukraine today is not likely to help anyone, and could actually make things worse, but Bitcoin might provide more options to other peoples, in other lands, in the future.

References:
http://www.thenation.com/blog/178716/dark-side-ukraine-revolthttp://www.counterpunch.org/2014/03/11/ukraine-the-enemy-of-your-enemy-is-not-always-your-friend/http://globalnews.ca/news/1194100/blind-eye-turned-to-influence-of-far-right-in-ukrainian-crisis-critics/

0 likes
  • adam

    Ever watch the news when somebody has set themselves on fire at a public building?  It's happened a few times in the states over the last couple years, and happens elsewhere in the world with more frequency.
    When a person chooses this as their preferred action, it is because it is the best of their available options as they perceive those options.   You only do it if you have completely given up hope and the sheer injustice of it all compared to your inability despite best efforts or intentions is enough to both demoralize and spur action.  It does not happen often, but when it does if it is a non-crazy person it speaks to something very broken in society.
    The important part though, is the perception of the individual making the decision.  An alternative is only helpful if they are aware of it, and so is the case with Ukraine and many others.  We can help explain, show them the way with our success but we can't dictate a solution to them.   They need to arrive at it, and it needs to be obvious.
    And it will be.  Probably not for Ukraine, not yet - but it's the painful, hair-on-fire experiance of Ukraine just as Cyprus before it that shows the world why a better way is so desperately needed.  The horrible warning that demands the evocation of many shining examples.

    Permalink
    0 likes
  • Omnio

    So why does the US want regime change in Syria, Iran, Ukraine, Venezuela and several other countries around the world all under the pretext of democracy? Is it possible that they want politicians in these countries that are easily malleable to their will unlike Yanukovych, so they can ultimately gain easy access to these countries' resources?

    Permalink
    0 likes
  • cmason


    Omnio, right, and why don't they ever care about regime change in places like Saudi Arabia or Bahrain?

    Permalink
    0 likes
  • Omnio

    Because the US is already happy with the status quo in those countries. Why would the US fix something if it's not broken? Oil and money is more important than some human rights violations.

    Permalink
    0 likes
  • cmason


    A short followup.  According to AFP, "14,500 of Ukraine's 18,800 soldiers in Crimea" politely informed their superiors they would remain in Crimea as members of the Russian military.
    http://www.google.com/hostednews/afp/article/ALeqM5g2AkYREUEAyKHmUn1y7Gf8Ipm1Mw?docId=3809cb85-ecfe-42ac-9644-35698a4a3d01


    Permalink
    0 likes
Jump to top

Post Reply

Please Login to post a reply to this thread.

© Copyright 2013–2016 The LTB Network. All rights reserved .